Makeup Product Reviews

Setting Spray Buying Guide: Finish and Label Claims

How setting sprays work, the finishes available, how to read claims such as 16-hour wear and which type suits your skin.

A setting spray is a fine mist applied as the last step of makeup. It helps products to stay in place, and it softens the powdery look that layers of makeup can leave. Sprays differ more than their similar bottles suggest. Some truly fix makeup, while others only refresh. The finish and the ingredients tell you which is which.

How this guide was put together

We grouped setting sprays by their typical ingredients and by what their labels state. Wear-time figures quoted on packaging come from makers' own tests. ArniSun has not verified them or tested individual sprays.

How setting sprays work

Most contain water, a film-forming ingredient and, often, alcohol.

  • Film-formers, such as PVP, acrylates copolymers and AMP-acrylates, dry into a thin, flexible layer over the makeup.
  • Alcohol helps the mist to dry quickly, so that makeup is not disturbed.
  • Humectants, such as glycerin, keep the finish from looking dry.

Setting spray, fixing spray or face mist?

ProductWhat it does
Setting sprayMelds makeup layers together; extends wear moderately
Fixing sprayStronger film; aims to lock makeup against sweat and transfer
Hydrating or facial mistRefreshes and adds moisture; little or no hold
Primer sprayUsed before makeup, to prepare the skin

The terms are used loosely. A spray with film-formers high in the ingredient list will hold more than one that is mostly water, glycerin and plant extracts.

Finishes

FinishLooksSuits
MatteReduces shineOily and combination skin; humid weather
NaturalSkin-likeMost skin types
Dewy or glowAdds sheenDry, dull or mature skin

Choosing by skin type

Skin typeLook forBe careful with
OilyMatte or oil-control spraysDewy, glycerin-heavy mists
DryHydrating, alcohol-free or low-alcohol spraysStrong matte fixing sprays
CombinationNatural finishExtremes of either kind
SensitiveFragrance-free, alcohol-freeFragrance, essential oils, high alcohol
Acne-proneNon-comedogenic, light formulasHeavy, oily mists
MatureHydrating or natural finishVery matte sprays, which emphasize lines

Understanding the claims

ClaimWhat it means
"16-hour", "24-hour" wearResult of the maker's test conditions; expect less in heat, humidity or with oily skin
"Waterproof", "sweat-proof"Stronger film; no spray makes makeup truly waterproof
"Transfer-proof"Reduces transfer; does not eliminate it
"Alcohol-free"Gentler; usually slower to dry and lighter in hold
"Oil-control"Contains mattifying powders or absorbers; shake well
"With SPF"Not a reliable way to apply enough sunscreen. See How to Reapply Sunscreen Over Makeup
"Hydrating", "soothing"More of a refreshing mist

The nozzle matters

A fine, even mist is essential. A nozzle that spits large droplets leaves spots, and can disturb makeup. Reviews often mention this, and it is worth checking.

How to apply

  1. Shake the bottle, if it contains powders or the label says so.
  2. Hold it about 20 to 25 cm from your face.
  3. Close your eyes and mouth.
  4. Mist in an "X", then a "T".
  5. Let it dry in the air. Do not touch your face.

For more hold, mist lightly after foundation and again at the end. To soften heavy powder, mist, then press gently with a damp sponge. See Cakey Foundation: Common Causes and Application Tips.

How it fits with powder and primer

You do not need all three every day. See Setting Powder vs Setting Spray: When to Use Each for powder and spray compared.

Possible downsides

  • Dryness or stinging with alcohol-heavy sprays, especially on dry or sensitive skin.
  • Irritation from fragrance.
  • Stickiness with some fixing sprays.
  • Clogged nozzle. Rinse it under warm water.

Avoid breathing in the mist, and keep it out of your eyes.

Do you need one?

A setting spray is useful for long days, events, hot weather and oily skin, and for refreshing makeup later. See Day-to-Night Makeup: How to Refresh Your Look. For short, everyday wear, with a light base, it is optional.

Value

Compare price per milliliter, and remember that a typical application uses very little. Travel sizes are handy for touch-ups.

Frequently asked questions

Does setting spray really work?

Sprays with film-forming ingredients help makeup to last longer and to look less powdery. They do not make makeup immovable.

Which setting spray is best for oily skin?

A matte or oil-control spray with a fine mist. Use powder on the T-zone first, for the best result.

Is setting spray bad for skin?

Not for most people. Alcohol and fragrance can dry or irritate sensitive skin, so choose alcohol-free and fragrance-free versions if needed, and remove makeup at night.

Tags

Written by

Sunil Dutt

Full Stake UI/UX Designer